The Virtues of Virtual Marking in Patent Reform

By McCaffrey, Corey

INTRODUCTION The world is full of reminders that we are surrounded by inventions. When we see a light bulb, we remember Thomas Edison.1 When we hear a telephone, we recall Alexander Graham Bell.2 But when we plot equations with a Texas Instruments (TI) graphing calculator, do we think of Ann Phipps? After all, like so many other products, the back of the TI-83 Plus is clearly marked with a list of patent numbers,3 including two naming Phipps as an inventor.4

In all probability, few of us know that Phipps was not only a product manager in TI's Consumer Products Division5 but that she was also one of the inventors of a "Calculator with Table Generation Capability."6 By marking the back of the calculator with the number of this patent, TI asserted that the TI-83 Plus embodied this invention. Yet, of all of the potentially relevant patents assigned to TI, Phipps's patents were two of only three listed on the back of this calculator.7 Surely, TI's primary intention was not to help make Phipps famous. More likely, TI marked patents on its product for legal effect.

Patent marking is defined by the United States Patent Act as the act of physically labeling a product or its packaging with the identification numbers of patents that ostensibly protect the inventive ideas embodied in the product.8 The purpose of patent marking is to help prevent innocent infringement. 9 Marking provides constructive notice that a product is protected by the listed patent(s).10 Notably, there are also penalties for abuses of the patent marking system, known as "false marking."11

This Comment argues in favor of permitting "virtual marking," whereby a patentee would be permitted to mark products with reference to a website that provides information about the product's patent protection.12 For example, imagine that instead of marking the back of a calculator with "Pat. 5532946," TI marked it with "Patents: http://ti.com/patents/calculators," and that website displayed nothing but "Pat. 5532946."13 At first glance, the distinction might seem trivial, but even this simple example of virtual marking has far-reaching implications for patent marking law.

The major advantage of virtual marking is that it untangles marking from the manufacturing process. Physical marking is expensive, inflexible, and increasingly inapplicable (e.g., for services and Internet products, which have no physical embodiment).

Invalid Picture Error - News


Report may point blame toward pilot of doomed Air France Airbus A330
Report may point blame toward pilot of doomed Air France Airbus A330

During the following seconds, all of the recorded speeds became invalid and the stall warning stopped. (When the measured speeds are below 60 knots, the measured angle of attack values are considered invalid and are not taken into account by the



The Virtues of Virtual Marking in Patent Reform

For example, patentees must change their marks when their patents expire or become invalid in the course of litigation. But high manufacturing costs prevent patentees from changing their marks cheaply and efficiently.14 Virtual marking would enable



Johnson letter to U.S. bishops' Doctrine Committee

Does this meaning render biblical female imagery for God invalid? Within the framework of the faith of the church arising in response to the treasure of God's historical self-disclosure or revelation, theology, in Anselm's classic description,



Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in i4i patent case
Supreme Court rules against Microsoft in i4i patent case

By your reasoning no one can patent an HTML editor, or a programing language compiler, picture editing program or even a file format or file system at all as they are all derivative of prior art. All patents on FAT, FAT32, NTFS etc. are all invalid.



Access denied

n.type FROM vocabulary v LEFT JOIN vocabulary_node_types n ON v.vid = n.vid WHERE v.vid = 0 in M:\news3-htdocs\news3\modules\taxonomy\taxonomy.module on line 986. warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in




** BD Rebuilder error "Invalid Picture" [ Doom9's Forum ]

Thanks for all the replies, it's appreciated. *@Capsbackup* That's one of the first things I tried but still the same error. *@setarip_old* I'm using the current version. All my downloads, including the support programs are from the first page of the BDRB bugs thread. I did download...Welcome to Doom9's ForumTHE in-place to be for everyone interested in DVD conversion.


Invalid Picture Error - Bookshelf

Microsoft Outlook programming, jumpstart for administrators, power users, and developers

Microsoft Outlook programming, jumpstart for administrators, power users, and developers

MsgBox strMsg, , "Invalid Picture Error" End If End If Set fso = Nothing End Sub bilities to programs, but also to create Web pages. ...

Essential Visual Basic 4

Essential Visual Basic 4


Standard codecs, image compression to advanced video coding

Standard codecs, image compression to advanced video coding

normal decoding cannot decode resync marker invalid codeword resync marker Figure 9.24 Error in a bit stream Note that data partitioning is only used for P ...

Visual Basic 5 database how-to, the definitive database problem-solver

Visual Basic 5 database how-to, the definitive database problem-solver

Ql 031 1 5 "PRB: Invalid Picture Error When Try To Bind Picture Control." If you have ever attempted to bind a PictureBox to an OLE Ob j ect database field ...

Perception Beyond Inference, The Information Content of Visual Processes

Perception Beyond Inference, The Information Content of Visual Processes

Thus, disparity does not satisfy the likelihood ratio condition under picture viewing and can therefore be considered an “invalid” image measure in the ...

Everyday Report Directory


Error 481 Invalid picture
Invalid picture error when I right click the exe and select "Run As" with a ... Invalid picture error when I right click the exe and select "Run As" with ...

invalid picture error message - SpywareInfo Forum
invalid picture error message: cant open hijack this or spyware guard

Atalasoft Community - RE: Cannot Trap Runtime error 481 ...
RE: Cannot Trap Runtime error 481 Invalid Picture ? Are you getting the error when running it from within the IDE? If so, check your error trapping ...

PRB: Invalid picture Error Trying to Bind Picture Control in VB 3
... to a Microsoft Access database field that contains an OLE object such as a PaintBrush bitmap, you will correctly receive the error "Invalid picture. ...

Runtime error 481 invalid picture - Pearson Assessment Support
saws Runtime error 481 invalid picture ... This error appears to indicate a possible conflict with other software that is running at the time of installation. ...
TOP